THE POLYGRAPH (“LIE DETECTOR”) TEST: IS IT ACCURATE?

7–11 minutes

Presumably possessing an aura of validity, polygraph testing is commonly used in the attempt to detect lies on popular TV crime shows and other media transmissions. Recently the U.S. government investigators have taken the unusual step of subjecting about 50 members of the U.S. military’s staff and civilian employees to polygraph tests in the effort to determine which ones might have leaked classified information to journalists about the Iran war, and this testing was apparently also motivated by an effort to discourage others from making similar disclosures in the future. However, this process raises questions about the general accuracy of polygraph testing.

CAN POLYGRAPHS DETECT LIES?

This test has been used for nearly a century, which, during questioning, continuously records a subject’s blood pressure, respiration, pulse rate, and skin resistance (an indirect measure of perspiration). The test records the activity of the sympathetic branch of the autonomic (involuntary) nervous system that influences heart rate, respiratory rate, blood pressure, and perspiration. These markers increase during excitement, rage, anxiety, fear or fright, any of which could be caused by lying. But deception is a cognitive function that defies direct measurement. Indeed, throughout the entire history of medical science, there have been no scientific studies that have shown that the emotional response linked to lying could be measured. Moreover, reactions associated with lying and any other assumed emotional stresses can be quite variable. Some people may stay calm with a gun at their head. By contrast, others may respond excessively with heart thumping and sweaty palms after simply shaking someone’s hand. And the polygraph examination itself often causes fear and anxiety, and if such responses are excessive in response to a given question, then one may be deemed to have failed that question by a polygraph examiner, and this reaction was supposed to indicate lying.

The usual polygraph format compares responses to “relevant” questions with those of “control” questions. The control questions are designed to control for the effect of the generally threatening nature of relevant questions. Control questions concern misdeeds that are similar to those being investigated, but they refer to a subject’s past that are usually broad in scope; for example, “Have you ever betrayed anyone who trusted you?” A person who is telling the truth is assumed to fear control questions more than relevant questions. This is because control questions are designed to arouse a subject’s concern about their past truthfulness, while relevant questions ask about a specific crime or a lie which they are currently suspected. A pattern of greater physiological response to relevant questions than to control questions leads to a diagnosis of “deception.” Greater response to control questions leads to a judgment of no deception. If no difference is found between relevant and control questions, the test result is considered “inconclusive.”

The Evidence

Because of this obvious biologic improbability in this era of evidence-based medical science, the premise of lie detection by polygraph has fallen under a cloud of skepticism, justly considered as pseudoscience by most of the scientific community. In order to be accepted by modern evidence, two test characteristics must be established—its sensitivity and specificity: Sensitivity is that percentage of positive test results when lying actually exists. Specificity is the percentage of negative results in the absence of prevarication. In order to establish the test’s accuracy, the presence of both lying and honesty must be known prior to—and independent of—the test procedure itself. True accuracy must be derived from real-life conditions because, for obvious reasons, it cannot be derived from volunteers in laboratory settings that lack the emotional pressures of real suspicion. To determine test specificity, a group without prevarication is tested to assess the results. But absolute proof of honesty is evasive in such individuals, because even if lying is absent, the anxiety associated with the test may falsely cause “positive” test results, reducing test specificity, which is a major confounder.

 Even more problematic, however, is in the determination of test sensitivity, which is derived from the frequency of “positive” test responses from criminal suspects who are “proven” to be guilty. Such guilty subjects—and many others that may be concealing lies—can purposely control their reactions (termed “countermeasures”), sufficiently to confuse the results enough to produce a “false negative.” One outstanding example of a false negative was that of Aldrich Ames, who, in 1995, had successfully passed five polygraphs during his long career in intelligence, and, despite this, he was subsequently arrested and convicted of spying. In 2003 another example was provided by Gary Ridgway, who eventually was found to be the Green River Killer, having murdered 49 women in the Seattle area. Ironically, Ridgway had passed a lie detector test in 1987, while another man—who was proved to be innocent—failed. These and other unknown factors act to reduce the sensitivity of this test to detect lying.

Critical and Scientific Study

The polygraph was not subjected to modern critical and scientific investigation until the past three decades. Since then, there have been several studies employing improved methodology which, despite the impossibility of achieving a completely satisfactory research design, clearly refute the high accuracy previously claimed. These studies have appeared in reputable peer-reviewed journals and generally report a sensitivity ranging around 76 percent and a specificity of 52 percent. This latter percentage means that out of 100 liars only 76 of them will be detected by the polygraph. And a specificity of 52 percent means that out of 100 people who are not lying, only 52 will be identified as telling the truth while 48 of these honest individuals will be branded as liars. These odds are similar to a coin toss of 50%.

In 2003, the National Academy of Sciences (NAS), after a comprehensive review, issued a report entitled “The Polygraph and Lie Detection, stating that the majority of polygraph research was “unreliable, unscientific and biased”, concluding that 57 of approximately 80 research studies—upon which the American Polygraph Association relies—were significantly flawed. It concluded that, although the test performed better than chance in catching lies—far from perfect—perhaps most importantly, they found the test produced an unacceptably high rate of false positives.

Justification for Continued Use?

For the reasons stated above, the continued use of polygraphic “lie detection” has the potential to cause much harm to those many innocents who are falsely judged dishonest by its results. A single failure could conceivably ruin one’s life. Since 1923, polygraph evidence has not been admissible in federal court cases because the test was deemed to lack scientific validity. Sadly, however, it is still used widely by the court systems of many states. Moreover, suspects are frequently “offered” this test prior to criminal proceedings, but if, for any reason, they decline to be tested, this refusal alone may cause them to be presumed guilty. Conversely, if they consent to being tested, they are risking the commonly occurring false positive outcome, which in the view of prosecutors and juries, supports a guilty verdict. Thus, from the standpoint of the accused, he/she is caught in a “catch 22” situation.

Even more regrettable is the attempted application of this testing in mixed populations composed mostly of truthful people, as exemplified by the military personnel noted above, or by for screening of groups for pre-employment or security clearance. If we apply in these situations a commonly used mathematical approach, known as Bayes theorem, most of the “positive” results will be found to be false because they are derived from the numerically dominant, “truthful,” proportion. Understanding these concepts, the American Medical Association’s Council on Scientific Affairs (1986) has recommended that the polygraph not be used in pre-employment screening and security clearance, which would also apply to the military group noted above. Adding clear restrictions to this testing, The Federal Employee Polygraph Protection Act, passed in 1988, virtually outlawed using polygraph testing in connection with screening of potential employees. This law also prohibits employers from discriminating against or firing those who claim its protections.

Federal applicants and employees are also generally protected from polygraph tests by civil service rules. Despite all these apparent safeguards, however, applicants often must undergo such testing in the quest of coveted security clearance for federal employment, or to retain such a job. The Employee Polygraph Protection Act allows polygraph tests to be used in connection with jobs in security and handling drugs, or in investigating a specific theft or other suspected crimes. Inexplicably, these examinations are used by agencies such as the FBI, CIA, and National Security Agency where they are commonplace. Applicants might expect them even before they start working at the agency. They may also be required to take follow-up polygraph tests periodically. But the first polygraph occurs at the initial screening. That often happens when, prior to a likely job offer, the only thing left is the polygraph test. The need to pass can be a very nervous event for anyone, especially those who have not been subjected to a polygraph before, and of course, as explained, this can easily trigger a false positive response, resulting in an unjustified rejection. Thus, the use of such a test for this purpose is very difficult to defend.

CONCLUSION

Although this form of testing fails as a scientifically credible test in virtually all other situations, especially for screening mixed groups containing mostly truthful individuals. Any current state or federal laws that allow use of polygraph testing in or outside of court settings, should be abolished. Unfortunately, however, various state and national polygraph certifying and licensing organizations—whose livelihood depends upon their own continued existence—are well entrenched in our society. Their provision of services to most law enforcement agencies creates a mutually supportive relationship that is difficult to overcome. Nevertheless, in order to eradicate this blight, it is incumbent on the scientific community, as well as others who understand these concepts, to educate the public about this perversion of science and relentlessly urge the responsible authorities to discontinue this present unsatisfactory status quo.

Below is a link to obtain my books available for purchase (digital or print versions):

https://www.amazon.com/s?k=morton+e+tavel&crid=2VZYYAPPD8OE1&sprefix=morton+e+tavel%2Caps%2C224&ref=nb_sb_noss

Website: https://radiantmortontavel.com/

To be placed on the mailing list for future blogs, contact: tavelmorton@gmail.com