Misinformation of all types is ubiquitous in our society, leading us to believe in falsehoods of many kinds, including false “cures” for diseases, belief in supernatural events or beings, false causes, and many others. When we purchase and test household products based on false claims, the damage is usually minor, for after you discover that said product fails to live up to its hype, you simply do not make the same purchase again and your damage is generally limited—hopefully—to the modest cost of your purchase. But the same doesn’t apply when phony claims extend to our general beliefs about the world around us, political events, and matters of personal health. In any of these situations, the results can be outright calamitous! It usually boils down to our ability to detect falsehoods, to which I will designate the general term, often known colloquially as “BS”.
First, for proper misinformation detection, we must adopt the tools of skeptical thought. Carl Sagan, renowned astrophysicist and popular science writer, has provided a set of tools called “the baloney detection kit”, which accords with my beliefs. Sagan states that skeptical thinking usually boils down to understanding the means to construct and understand a reasoned argument. More importantly, however, this process involves learning to detect a fraudulent argument, i.e. misinformation. It is not a matter of whether we like or dislike a specific conclusion; regardless how personally inimical, we must learn to begin with a valid premise and then follow logically to a given conclusion.
Listed below are a few of the tools that allow for the detection of falsehoods:
1. Whenever possible there must be independent confirmation of the underlying “facts,” usually involving debate on the evidence by knowledgeable proponents of all points of view.
2. Arguments from “authorities” carry little weight in themselves and are often misleading. In science there are no authorities; at most, there are experts. Other individuals, such as politicians, are far more difficult to pin down, and most are neither experts nor authorities, especially in the present environment!
3. Prior to any conclusions, consider more than one hypothesis. Think of different explanations and various objective means that could be used to test each hypothesis. The final selection among multiple working hypotheses is usually the simplest and has a much better chance of being the right answer. Needless to say, do not run with the first idea that caught your fancy. In other words, don’t fall in love with a hypothesis just because it’s yours.
4. Whenever possible, quantify your data numerically. This allows for more objective discrimination among competing hypotheses. Some presumptions are simply not amenable to numerical analysis, and these are less easy to prove.
5. If there’s a chain of arguments, every link of this chain must work, not just most of them.
6. All hypotheses must be falsifiable. Skeptics must be given the chance to duplicate your experiments and arrive at the same result. Propositions that are not falsifiable are useless. One great example is that of “intelligent design”, i.e., the idea that an ethereal being created our human species approximately 6,000 to 10,000 years ago in its current form. While we know for certain that humans existed far longer than that time span, we can neither prove nor disprove that a cosmic force of unknown nature played a role in producing this final product and plopping it down on earth.
7. It is false to believe that whatever has not been proven to be false must be true. For instance, since there is no compelling evidence that UFOs (now called UAPs, “unidentified aerial phenomena”) are not visiting the Earth, it must inevitably follow that they actually exist, and from this assertion, there must be intelligent life elsewhere in the universe. Or another variant on this theme: Since the presence of a supernatural creator of humankind has not been “disproved”, something along these lines must be proven to exist.
These are but a few of the fallacies of logic that lead both to the acceptance as well as the rejection—of falsehoods! In all such situations, we must always be vigilant and seek out objective confirmation of conclusions, constantly looking for alternative and/or new explanations that might offer a better solution. This is how humanity, in the form of knowledge, advances!
For more tips about facts and myths check my website at https://radiantmortontavel.com/
Below are links to access my books available for purchase (digital or print versions):
To be placed on the mailing list for future blogs, contact: tavelmorton@gmail.com
