WHY ARE BIOMEDICAL SCIENTISTS BEING VILIFIED?

4–7 minutes

   I was shocked recently when I read the book entitled “The Deadly Rise of Anti Science” by Peter Hotez, MD, a renowned biomedical science researcher, who is an American physician-scientist, vaccine researcher, and one of the most prominent public voices in the fight against anti-science movements. He serves as Dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine, where he also holds professorships in pediatrics and molecular virology and microbiology. Hotez is best known for two things: 1) developing low-cost vaccines for diseases that disproportionately affect the world’s poorest populations and 2) using his platform to push back against vaccine misinformation. His work sits at the intersection of laboratory science, global health policy, and public advocacy, which has made him both widely respected and, paradoxically, a frequent target of anti-vaccine groups. This latter issue that shocked me most were the vicious attacks, including death threats, that were caried out by anti-science groups. These attacks were directed against Hotez and other fellow colleagues that included Anthony Fauci, MD, an American scientist who, as director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Disease (NIAID, 1984–2022), who played a key role in diagnosing and treating a number of contagious illnesses, notably AIDS and COVID-19. Sadly, according to a recent survey of biomedical researchers, 40% of those surveyed have suffered from similar abusive threats to them and/or their family members

    So, why are such attacks occurring against such renowned medical researchers who seem to have nothing but the most benevolent intentions to enhance the world’s health and reducing death rates? In general, the scientific method is defined as principles and procedures for the systematic pursuit of knowledge involving the recognition and formulation of a problem, the collection of data through observation and experiment, and the formulation and testing of hypotheses Therefore, one might characterize the scientific process merely as seeking the truth, free of biases or political leanings. Since attackers against such learned doctors possess little or no scientific knowledge, their claims are seldom credible. For instance, claims that the vaccines are dangerous by producing autism in children have been overwhelmingly debunked by numerous well documented studies. Other claims that these researchers are acting as shills for the pharmaceutical companies or other financial organizations are refuted because they lack even a shred of evidence for such shady activities. Claims that such vaccines are unsafe have been refuted by numerous large statistical analyses. Although both anti science and vaccination beliefs have been present in this nation for many years, they have intensified during the recent COVID epidemic and were widely supported by President Trump, along with many Republican right-wing political extremists, and also by media as represented by Fox News and others. The role of greed in the anti-vaccine movement is also a factor, since quack medicine is big business. Right-wing radio and social media have long relied on peddlers of false cures (“snake oil”) such as ivermectin and hydroxychloroquine for much of their revenue. This is not to discount the role of ignorance driven by ideology. The same bias seems to pervade the autocratic nations that are at odds with the truth.

      In this nation, most of the attacks against bio-science researchers originate from right leaning, Republican dominated (red) states that suffer the highest mortality from diseases that are attributable to lack of vaccinations. Paradoxically, these are the same states that promote policies responsible for their own deaths! Unfortunately, even our state of Florida represents one of those red states that pose a danger to science and vaccinations: In March 2022, Florida became the first state to recommend against COVID-19 vaccinations of children without underlying conditions, going against the recommendations of both the federal drug administration (FDA) and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Later, in October 2022, Florida also recommended against this vaccination for males 18-39 years of age. Officially the recommendation came from the Florida Health Dept’s Dr. Joseph Ladapo, the state Surgeon General. But the initial impetus likely arose from anti-vaccine roundtable discussions organized by Governor Ron Desantis. When vaccines first rolled out in January 2021, DeSantis voiced support for vaccinating Florida’s seniors, but later he began consulting with groups of contrarian physicians who were very public in their opposition to COVID vaccinations and other preventive measures. Dr. Ladapo himself has been linked to the “Americas Frontline Doctors” group, which is a notorious American right-wing political organization that has promoted misinformation related to the COVID-19 pandemic, and opposed mitigation measures such as business closures, stay-at-home orders, and vaccines. The homepage of this organization’s website claimed that it promotes “health freedom” by (1) “Protecting physician independence and (2) “Fighting medical cancel culture and media censorship”. But Florida’s health freedom zealotry has gone even beyond vaccinations. For instance, Desantis publicly mocked college students who wore masks at an event, claiming masks were nothing more than “COVID theater”.  Sadly, most red states have been outspoken in their opposition to any sort of vaccine mandates. In 2021, many of these governors banded together to oppose mandated vaccines for schools, the workplace, or state governments, usually branding them as evidence of “government overreach”. When this issue reached the Supreme Court, the Justices ruled on the side of these Republican governors with a predictable 6-3 margin that such mandates violated state sovereignty and personal health freedoms. The result of this ill-advised decision was predictable: Deaths per capita in America’s reddest counties were almost three times as high as in its bluest counties–a direct result of vaccine denial. Many lessons from history make it clear that vaccinations are not only effective, but to really be successful, they must be universally applied, mandatory if necessary! Sadly, we are already witnessing a return of our past dread diseases such as measles, which are resulting from such “health freedoms” emanating from many anti-science political leaders.     

    Needless to say, maximum effort must be made to protect those scientists that protect the public by providing the underlying research that enables the future development of lifesaving preventions and treatments.

Below is a link to obtain my books available for purchase (digital or print versions):

https://www.amazon.com/s?k=morton+e+tavel&crid=2VZYYAPPD8OE1&sprefix=morton+e+tavel%2Caps%2C224&ref=nb_sb_noss

Website: https://radiantmortontavel.com/

To be placed on the mailing list for future blogs, contact: tavelmorton@gmail.com

Below is a link to obtain my books available for purchase (digital or print versions):

https://www.amazon.com/s?k=morton+e+tavel&crid=2VZYYAPPD8OE1&sprefix=morton+e+tavel%2Caps%2C224&ref=nb_sb_noss

Website: https://radiantmortontavel.com/

To be placed on the mailing list for future blogs, contact: tavelmorton@gmail.com