HOW YOU VOTE COULD BE FATAL

3–5 minutes

Recently I received from my cousin, Sheila Kennedy (who writes an excellent blog sheila@sheilakennedy.net), a summary of an important topic concerning how political affiliation can be deadly. It follows:

   You’ve probably seen reports that the government is blocking the publication of peer-reviewed studies confirming the efficacy of Covid and Shingles vaccines. But for a truly chilling account of the dwindling life-expectancy of Americans thanks to our Right wing government, you can’t beat a recent analysis by Paul Krugman–complete with charts and depressing data. Krugman recently published “MAGA Will Kill Many Americans,” and accompanied that rather shocking headline with even more shocking data showing that life expectancy in the United States has become substantially lower than in other advanced countries. Instead, we’re on a par with nations like Albania. This is a relatively recent departure; in the early 1980s, American life expectancy was on par with that of other rich nations. So, what happened in the 1980s? A sharp political turn to the right. And as Krugman shows, “there is a strong correlation between right-wing politics and increased mortality.” Lest you dismiss that observation as overwrought, he provides a graph correlating life expectancies with the percentage of the Trump vote in the states. 

    Taking population sizes into account, the trend line through the data points shows that there is there’s a strong, clear negative correlation between Trump-leaning orientation and low life expectancy at the state level. Deep red states like Alabama and West Virginia have life expectancy comparable to, say, Kazakhstan. Why is this? Red States have weak social safety nets; they provide little or no healthcare to vulnerable populations. Many refused to expand Medicaid under the Affordable Care Act, even though the federal government would have paid most of the cost. But it goes beyond the aversion to providing a social safety net–as we’ve seen and as Krugman reminds us, right-wing politics in America these days “goes hand in hand with hostility to science in general and medical science in particular.” (During the Covid pandemic, deaths per capita in America’s reddest counties were almost three times as high as in its bluest counties–a direct result of vaccine denial.)

The question, of course, is why the political right opposes the provision of healthcare. Krugman says it has a lot to do with greed, beginning with the wealthy donors who are unwilling to pay taxes to help the less fortunate.

Greed is also an important factor in the attack on medical science. The best-known example of scientific disinformation promoted by corporate interests is the fossil-fuel-financed attack on climate science, but the template for this attack was the earlier campaign by the tobacco industry’s “merchants of doubt” to discredit evidence that smoking is harmful to your health. The role of greed in the anti-vaccine movement may be less obvious, but the fact is that quack medicine is big business. Right-wing radio and social media have long relied on peddlers of snake oil for a large part of their revenue. So much of the attack on medical science can be seen as financially motivated. Which is not to discount the role of willful ignorance driven by ideology. The modern U.S. right is, to a large extent, an alliance between oligarchs and white Christian nationalists — and the latter are deeply hostile to enlightenment values, modern science very much included.

    Given a Republican Party and government dominated by White Christian nationalists, Americans no longer live as long as those in other rich countries. Among the states, Texans die younger than residents of Massachusetts. Meanwhile, millions of Americans in all the states will lose health insurance this year, thanks to Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill” with its drastic cuts to the ACA and Medicaid.

    Although Krugman didn’t mention it, in the wake of the Dobbs decision, many red states enacted draconian abortion bans which have increased maternal deaths.

    MAGA’s anti-science ideology is what prompted officials at the Food and Drug Administration to block publication of several studies confirming the safety of widely used vaccines. According to the New York Times, those studies cost millions of taxpayer dollars. They were conducted by scientists at the agency who analyzed millions of patient records. The studies found serious side effects to be very rare. The Times went on to state that the withdrawal of the studies is simply the latest of efforts by the administration to limit access to vaccines. It has also cut research funding for vaccine development and released unvetted–and misleading– information casting doubt on vaccines.

   As a conventionally trained physician, I could not agree more heartily with these observations!

Welcome to a shorter life in a third-world country!

Below is a link to obtain my books available for purchase (digital or print versions):

https://www.amazon.com/s?k=morton+e+tavel&crid=2VZYYAPPD8OE1&sprefix=morton+e+tavel%2Caps%2C224&ref=nb_sb_noss

Website: https://radiantmortontavel.com/

To be placed on the mailing list for future blogs, contact: tavelmorton@gmail.com